5 Thrifty Easter Alternatives to Real Eggs for Decorating

Overview

With egg prices on the rise, decorating real eggs feels less practical. Thankfully, this article offers smart, affordable, and eco-conscious substitutes that preserve the festive flair—without breaking the bank.


5 Creative Alternatives to Decorating Real Eggs

  1. Potatoes as “Eggs”
    Use small, egg-shaped potatoes painted or decorated like real eggs. They mimic the familiar form—and if you choose biodegradable paint, they may even be compostable.Potatoes-h-aadb59bc3f9e4704b6499995680000df

  2. Wooden Eggs
    These smooth, long-lasting blanks offer a perfect canvas for paint, washi tape, glitter, or decoupage. They look and feel closest to real eggs—but with lasting reuse potential.Wood-Eggs-h-333c29fe7fbe48c38f7edf167a675901

  3. Pasta Shell “Eggs”
    Crafted by painting large shell-shaped pasta, these quirky pieces add unexpected charm. Bonus: the pasta can still be used in the kitchen afterward.Pasta-Shells-h-4b5253e28fb047ce80047f163dcc7004

  4. Paper Eggs
    Made from recycled paper, these eco-friendly alternatives absorb dyes and markers beautifully, and can be stashed away for next year’s celebrations.Paper-eggs-h-e0c5babd1f634da29769155843058d62

  5. Air-Dry Clay Eggs
    Mold your own egg shapes with air-dry clay—perfect for painting and customizing. Imperfections become part of the charm, especially when painted over.Air-Dry-Clay-h-97b0be41785e43acb275f22979d5784c


Quick Comparison

Alternative Pros Reusability
Potatoes Affordable, realistic shape, compostable potential One-time use
Wooden Eggs Durable, customizable, classic feel Reusable annually
Pasta Shells Quirky, fun, then useful as food One-time crafting
Paper Eggs Eco-friendly, lightweight, easy to decorate Reusable if saved
Clay Eggs Custom shapes, painted look Reusable if stored

Why These Alternatives Work

These creative options sidestep the expense of real eggs while offering versatility, sustainability, and style. Whether you want something recyclable, reusable, or uniquely playful, there’s an alternative that suits your aesthetic and budget.